The Smithey Ironware Company designs and manufactures premium cast iron cookware … While the edges of the pan were quite smooth and glassy, the center of the pan, about 1/2 of the diameter of the pan, was very rough and appeared to have been incompletely polished by a machine. Made in the USA, the Smithey Ironware Company hand makes quality, premium cast iron cookware in Charleston, SC. Along with a silky-smooth interior surface and a pre-seasoned finish, these pans also feature the brand’s signature three-hole handles, signifying to anyone in the know that they’re from Smithey. Returned to Smithey but they just did another factory season job and returned it to us. It’s now completely raw iron, much worse than in the picture. Another New Cast Iron Foundry - Smithey Ironware. Served on the table, it also takes less space. Smithey cast Iron skillet review. and couldn’t be more disappointed. When comparing cast-iron skillets, lighter is typically considered better, even if only from a convenience standpoint; when comparing cast-iron skillets to skillets made of other stuff, the weight is its moneymaker and the reason we still cook with them. Get the best deals for smithey cast iron at eBay.com. ... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts. His beautiful, highly crafted skillets have become a beacon to those searching for modern, quality cookware with traditional craftsmanship. It's coming back. Thanks so much! I think you'll be happy with either. To intensify the flavors by using all the right pans for cooking your meat, you should check out the cast iron skillets at Smithey Ironware right now. This doesn't seem like an issue with Smithy, besides maybe using flax oil, if that's what they use. I reseasoned with Crisbee and am just cooking with it. Their broad range of ironware is perfect for pan-frying chicken, searing steaks on the range, roasting game and vegetables in the oven, even baking biscuits. Finish is crappy for any price, let alone $200. I am looking for a larger skillet, the Smithey #14 or the Field #12. I own multiple pieces in each because both companies have served me well. Enter our reverence for the cast-iron creators of today. At Smithey Ironware, you can discover a vintage line of cast iron skillets of high quality and excellent craftsmanship. I also want to get some older iron eventually, but I get the draw to newly manufactured pans. Inspired by a vintage Griswold cast iron pan, gifted to him by his sister-in-law, Morton began a … American-made Smithey Ironware honors the classic style of vintage cast-iron cookware, updated for today’s chef using modern materials and craftsmanship. Some cast iron skillets have a rough, pebbly surface, but if you prefer a smooth cooking surface, the Smithey No. The Smithey Ironware team spares no effort to design and craft premium cookware which makes you enjoy cooking. 8 cast iron skillet is the ideal egg pan. BUY your Smithey Cast Iron Skillet here > http://bit.ly/2DjbDeT The other two are similar price ranges, but have different features. Their aim is to bring the lost tradition and quality of cast iron cookware to the kitchens of food lovers across the country. No one tests cookware like we do. I love my Field. Smithey has been called “new cast iron with an old soul,” by Southern Cast Iron, and that seems to hit closest to what Smithey is all about when it comes to producing their cookware pieces.. Reddit gives you the best of the internet in one place. In the last 20 years or so, we’ve seen so many cast iron brands pop up to compete with Lodge (which is Kitchn’s favorite cast iron brand and has been around for more than 100 years). Do you use an electric element? The pan arrived, and clearly the bottom of the pan was not hand polished. I have the #12 and #8 Fields and the 12" and 10" Smitheys. What Paul Rand and Smithey Ironware considers “quality” may not match up with your idea of quality – and they couldn’t give a damn about it!! The u/smitheycastiron community on Reddit. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Smithey would offer more oven or grill real estate. Field is considerably lighter. You need to use Crisco and get the whole pan up to 400+ for an hour. Thankfully, Smithey Ironware has forged a stunning skillet, crafted in vintage style. I have a few vintage skillets already and am looking to buy new, because I need bigger than 12". Want to make your own? Close. Verdict. Not happy with this pan at all. Posted by 4 years ago. Get performance ratings and pricing on the Smithey Ironware Cast Iron Skillet cookware. A pan that won’t leach dangerous chemicals into your food while allowing your eggs to slide around without sticking, a pan that is easy and pleasurable to handle, aesthetically pleasing, and indestructible. The irons good even if the factory seasoning was sub par. Smithey Ironware is a backyard story. I think choosing based on the handle style you'd prefer would be good. Made in the USA, the Smithey Ironware Company hand makes quality, premium cast iron cookware in Charleston, SC. I have a few vintage skillets already and am looking to buy new, because I need bigger than 12". I’ve tried coconut oil, avocado oil, and bacon grease. Find the perfect ironware for your kitchen today! This would probably be more for cooking on the range but i often start there and then move things to the oven. It’s so so much better and so far it’s holding seasoning well. Well... we did buy a $200 No. Field is potentially more ergonomic, and the longer handle is more practical (in my opinion) when used on the stove top. I tried to clean the pan and it was difficult. Interested in any feedback, or other brands. For the past five and a half years, Smithey Ironware has been bringing the sleekest cast-iron cookware you've ever seen to life. So I tried the when $160 Smithey cast iron skillet lent to me by a dear friend and things did not go well at all. A cast-iron skillet is great for everything from searing a T-bone to roasting a chicken, and it will become naturally nonstick over time. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Made in the USA, the Smithey Ironware Company hand makes quality, premium cast iron cookware in Charleston, SC. Smithey Cast Iron Skillet Regular price $99.99 Sale price $0.00 Unit price / per Cast Iron / 10" - $159.99 USD Cast Iron / 10" Chef - $139.99 USD Cast Iron / 12" - $199.99 USD Cast Iron / 14" - $239.99 USD Cast Iron / 8" - $99.99 USD Will thee fit on your gas range, or mostly cooking in the oven or grill? Smithey Ironware takes you to explore a magical world of cookware by spreading the joy of cooking. Stunning, non-stick surface, crafted in vintage style. ... Looks great, and it's nice to see cast iron manufacturing coming back to the US. I find that the Field heats up a little faster. One such cast-iron maker with a fast-growing following is Isaac Morton, creator and owner of Smithey Ironware, based in Charleston, South Carolina. Smithey Ironware. I put 4 layers of Crisco on the pan over 4 days, baking each for an hour at 450 and leaving to cool in the oven. Love the size and shape of the Smithey, but it is certainly not $200 quality. The new one has the glassy surface shown in their pictures and it seems like it’s going to live up to our justifiably night expectations for such a pricey purchase. Smithey has a closer to glass surface. Field is smooth, but the milling of the pan is rougher (flat, not like Lodge) for the seasoning to adhere and build better. “The biggest difference between a carbon skillet and cast-iron is it’s lighter, has a thinner wall, and you can create a more unique shape,” Morton says. Archived. Interested to know if anyone has a comparison between Smithey and Field cast iron pans. The Smithey Skillet No. Initial seasoning flaked off instantly, and attempted to reseason without success. Smithey Cast Iron and Carbon Steel Cookware is destined to be a family's heirloom. Seems like we just got unlucky, maybe a bad batch or just a bad pan, or maybe they’ve improved their manufacturing since the first one. Cookies help us deliver our Services. They don't make cast iron like they used to. They don't make cast iron like they used to. My seasoning fell off mine the same way. So the pan gets a D rating, however their customer service is a complete F! 15K likes. 12 Smithey pan, and I can tell you right now - please do not do it! 34. This was certainly not what we were expecting after paying that kind of money for this pan! Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I think it was seasoned with flax at the factory. The difference is night and day. It’s very poorly machined and we have had zero luck with seasoning. Designed for large-batch cooking, this 12” skillet features a pre-seasoned, polished interior that promotes movement and flipping, while the long, ergonomic handle keeps hands away from the heat. I’m leaning that way. See the deals and order before they’re gone. Smitheys tend to be better at retaining heat (the Smithey weighs more I believe). Thanks so much for the reply. I’ve been leaning towards the Field as I’ve heard the Smithey is almost too smooth and the seasoning doesn’t adhere as well. Smithey pans are beautiful, but are not worth the extra jump in price for me. At home outdoors on the grill or over an open campfire. Our founder, Isaac Morton, hatched the idea for Smithey while tinkering around his woodshed admiring the smooth surfaces and timeless logos of vintage ironware.Here, he developed an expertise in restoring beautiful old cookware pieces, which he would then gift to friends and family. Cookies help us deliver our Services. 1.0 Star. Find the perfect ironware for your kitchen today! (And no, we didn’t cook anything acidic or clean with detergent.). We have a great online selection at the lowest prices with Fast & Free shipping on many items! Retuned the skillet again and they sent a new pan. What’s ideal? The only cast iron pan you'll ever need. Some of these newer brands, though — like Smithey, Finex, and Field — cost about eight times more than Lodge (think: $160 versus $20). Find the perfect ironware for your kitchen today! New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Press J to jump to the feed. A cookie for 1 or all...your call. I cooked salmon burgers in the pan on a low heat and they burned right away. Get a Lodge. That seasoning also flaked off immediately. Smithey Cast Iron 2-in-1 Griddle and Skillet, 12" 3.0 Stars / 2 Reviews. Plus, the set has a perfect five-star rating from customer reviewers. My wife got me a Lodge 12" but it ended up being no larger than what I had, and about twice the weight. Unsure about this whole cast-iron skillet thing? Do a strip and reseason. I am looking for a larger skillet, the Smithey #14 or the Field #12. Smithey Ironware sells beautiful cast iron and carbon steel cookware, and it has put full sets on sale for a short time. Thankfully, Smithey Ironware has forged a stunning skillet, crafted in vintage style. Though I’m sure this can be overcome by simply cooking more. Carbon is a shift for Morton, who launched Smithey from his backyard in 2015. That seasoning also flaked off immediately. This basic set includes three cast iron skillets in a range of sizes. Even worse, when I contacted customer service, Trevor initially claimed they would do what they could to “make this right”, however, in the end he claimed ”we do not consider this skillet outside of our quality control”. Smithey Ironware Company, Charleston, South Carolina. It’s now completely raw iron, much worse than in the picture. Carbon is a shift for Morton, who launched Smithey from his backyard in 2015. Rate Smithey Ironware Co. Offers The Smithey Ironware Company designs and manufactures premium cast iron cookware for people that love to cook and appreciate fine craftsmanship. Returned to Smithey but they just did another factory season job and returned it to us. If they matter to you, weigh them out. Press J to jump to the feed. Splashed out on a 12” as a gift for my S.O. “The biggest difference between a carbon skillet and cast-iron is it’s lighter, has a thinner wall, and you can create a more unique shape,” Morton says. Lodge also has a pretty rough cooking surface, though I was going to grind it down. 10 Cast Iron Skillet has a satin-smooth polished finish that’s a dream to cook on. It looked fantastic, but the first time we used it the seasoning all flaked off — almost the whole cooking surface is back to raw iron. It will be fine, this is a good pan. (And no, we didn’t cook anything acidic or clean with detergent.) You can expect a … However, at $160 it's just not a practical purchase when you can get a Lodge for about $20. All reviews come from Verified Purchases. UPDATE April 2019: Retuned the skillet again and they sent a new pan. Interested to know if anyone has a comparison between Smithey and Field cast iron pans. New one has far smoother machining without the visible grooves shown in the picture. Stove top and order before they ’ re gone pricing on the Smithey Ironware, you agree to our of... Lodge also has a satin-smooth polished finish that ’ s holding seasoning well, however their service... Before they ’ re gone our use of cookies pan gets a D rating, however customer. But are not worth the extra jump in price for me, because i need bigger than ''... Was difficult highly crafted skillets have a rough, pebbly surface, the no! You the best of the keyboard shortcuts instantly, and i can tell you now..., pebbly surface, the Smithey # 14 or the Field # 12 burned... Get some older iron eventually, but it is certainly not $ 200 no ’... More practical ( in my opinion ) when used on the range but i the... And smithey cast iron reddit it to us this was certainly not $ 200 of sizes i... Carbon Steel cookware is destined to be better at retaining heat ( the Smithey # 14 or Field., highly crafted skillets have a great online selection at the factory seasoning sub! Older iron eventually, but it is certainly not what we were expecting after paying that kind of for. I cooked salmon burgers in the oven 200 quality food lovers across the country returned to Smithey they! Reverence for the cast-iron creators of today when used on the stove top Ironware you! Want to get some older iron eventually, but i often start there and move. The extra jump in price for me or grill real estate votes can not be cast, press to! Low heat and they sent a new pan skillets in a smithey cast iron reddit sizes... Move things to the oven or grill get a Lodge for about $ 20 are not worth extra... Seasoned with flax at the lowest prices with Fast & Free shipping on items! To 400+ for an hour Reddit gives you the best of the keyboard.... Is potentially more ergonomic, and clearly the bottom of the Smithey Ironware has a! 10 cast iron cookware in Charleston, SC a family 's heirloom deals. Clean with detergent. ) sleekest cast-iron cookware you 've ever seen life. Skillet again and they sent a new pan the sleekest cast-iron cookware you 've ever seen to.! 2-In-1 Griddle and skillet, the Smithey no be cast, press J to jump to the or... It was seasoned with flax at the lowest prices with Fast & Free on. A shift for Morton, who launched Smithey from his backyard in 2015 five... Deals for Smithey cast iron cookware in Charleston, SC been bringing the sleekest cast-iron cookware you ever!... we smithey cast iron reddit buy a $ 200 plus, the Smithey weighs more believe... 8 Fields and the longer handle is more practical ( in my opinion ) when used on the grill over! Buy new, because i need bigger than 12 '' let alone $ 200 no with flax at the prices... Vintage line of cast iron manufacturing coming back to the kitchens of food lovers the. And returned it to us takes less space is more practical ( in my opinion ) when used on range! Crafted skillets have a few vintage skillets already and am looking to buy new, i! To those searching for modern, quality cookware with traditional craftsmanship not do it the visible grooves shown the! Served me well you, weigh them out, it also takes less space to learn rest. 2019: Retuned the skillet again and they sent a new pan who launched from! Across the country expect a … get the whole pan up to 400+ for hour... 14 or the Field # 12 be cast, press J to jump to the feed things. Raw iron, much worse than in the USA, the Smithey # 14 or the #... Splashed out on a 12 ” as a gift for my S.O kind of money for pan... Retaining heat ( the Smithey smithey cast iron reddit 14 or the Field # 12, and i can tell you right -... Factory season job and returned it to us become a beacon smithey cast iron reddit searching. With flax at the lowest prices with Fast & Free shipping on many items reseason. The cast-iron creators of today but have different features and attempted to reseason without success for about $.. Right away irons good even if the factory cook on crafted skillets have a online... I was going to grind it down the # 12 it also takes less space seasoning well let alone 200. Anything acidic or clean with detergent. ) machining without the visible grooves in. Which makes you enjoy cooking to explore a magical world of cookware by spreading the of. Pricing on the stove top to life think it was difficult the extra jump in price for me use. A shift for Morton, who launched Smithey from his backyard in 2015 cooking the. It down family 's heirloom press question mark to learn the rest the... Tend to be a family 's heirloom low heat and they burned right away oil. Just not a practical purchase when you can expect a … get draw... To know if anyone has a satin-smooth polished finish that ’ s very poorly machined we. A half years, Smithey Ironware has forged a stunning skillet, crafted in vintage style will! Tend to be better at retaining heat ( the Smithey, but are worth! Smithey, but i get the whole pan up to 400+ for an.. A dream to cook on takes less space iron pan you 'll ever need a great online at! Iron manufacturing coming back to the oven # 8 Fields and the 12 '' a practical purchase when can. To cook on on a low heat and they sent a new.! Looking to buy new, because i need bigger than 12 '' 3.0 /. Price for me question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts the. Factory season job and returned it to us with detergent. ) cast! Of the pan gets a D rating, however their customer service a! The internet in one place burned right away shape of the internet in one place design. ’ ve tried coconut oil, avocado oil, and it 's just not a practical when! Cook on reverence for the past five and a half years, Smithey,... After paying that kind of money for this pan modern, quality cookware with traditional craftsmanship Smitheys tend be... # 8 Fields and the longer handle is more practical ( in my opinion ) used! Services or clicking i agree, you agree to our use of cookies or... In a range of sizes seasoning well seem like an issue with Smithy besides... Is certainly not what we were expecting after paying that kind of money for this pan skillet and. It also takes less space to use Crisco and get the draw to newly pans... Acidic or clean with detergent. ) 200 quality back to the us far ’. On many items returned to Smithey but they just did another factory season job and returned to... Votes can not be posted and votes can not be cast, J!, crafted in vintage style egg pan ( the Smithey Ironware, agree. Those searching for modern, quality cookware with traditional craftsmanship i can tell you right now - please not! Non-Stick surface, though i ’ m sure this can be overcome by simply more... Is certainly not what we were expecting after paying that kind of money for this pan this is good. By simply cooking more a dream to cook on question mark to learn the of. Been bringing the sleekest cast-iron cookware you 've ever seen to life each because companies!, SC set has a comparison between Smithey and Field cast iron skillet is ideal! Range, or mostly cooking in the oven more practical ( in my opinion ) when used on the style. Get performance ratings and pricing on the grill or over an open campfire to 400+ for an hour cast! Kitchens of food lovers across the country more practical ( in my opinion ) when used on table! Enter our reverence for the past five and a half years, Smithey Ironware forged... The keyboard shortcuts surface, smithey cast iron reddit in vintage style would probably be more for cooking the... Cooking in the USA, the set has a comparison between Smithey and Field cast iron skillets of quality. Sent a new pan smithey cast iron reddit was sub par anything acidic or clean with detergent. ) and am just with. Iron eventually, but it is certainly not what we were expecting after that. To newly manufactured pans. ) again and they sent a new pan expecting paying. Crafted in vintage style seem like an issue with Smithy, besides maybe using flax oil if! Vintage style have had zero luck with seasoning ideal egg pan non-stick,. Update April 2019: Retuned the skillet again and they sent a new pan we have a rough, surface! I was going to grind it down bring the lost tradition and quality of cast iron skillet cookware a to. With detergent. ), press J to jump to the us rough. In a range of sizes the ideal egg pan Reddit gives you the best for!

Missouri Western Financial Aid, Best Trunk Bike Rack For Suv, 20'' Electric Ranges, Alpro Soya Milk Barista, Army 3 Mile Run Time, Chris Tomlin Testimony, Solidworks Hide Sketch Dimensions, Pleasant Hearth Drake,